ObamaCare: Robbing Peter to Pay…No One.

I should know better than to think, “They can’t be serious proposing that!” But the Democrats’ fix for healthcare sends even my shock-and-surprise meter into red zone.

The President’s self-styled Health Reform Plan, or ObamaCare, reforms [fixes] nothing. It robs Peter to pay…whom? No one?

ObamaCare calls for $1.5 trillion (yes, with a “t”) dollars in new expenses. These supposedly will be offset by three mechanisms: 1) Income tax surcharge on the top 0.1% of wage earners (”$544b”); 2) Cuts in MediCaid and MediCare spending (”$500b”); and 3) Penalties on individuals and companies who do not purchase insurance (”$200b”).

Testifying before the Senate Budget Committee, the Director of the CBO (Congressional Budget Office) said that ObamaCare would accelerate, not slow the health cost spiral and that the Administration’s revenue calculations were “unrealistic’ [he was being gentle].

ObamaCare is a classic fix-that-fails (from systems thinking).  No, wait. That is wrong. It is worse. It is a fix-that-backfires. Think about it from two viewpoints: effect on your health care and effect of the economy.

Effect on your health care
Your doctor does not accept new Medicare patients not because she is a money-grubbing capitalist. She just wants to stay in business. What MediCare pays does not cover her marginal costs. With a large enough number of MediCare patients, the doctor cannot make payroll. And now the Obama Plan will cut MediCare payments even further!

Let’s say for discussion’ sake that ObamaCare actually does increase the number of people with health insurance coverage. What good is having insurance if the doctor won’t see you? She cannot see you because she cannot afford to. Recall the commercial: “More taste! Less Filling!” ObamaCare is More Insurance! Less Care!

Additionally, ObamaCare is likely to worsen the quality of health care. No joke. At the same time as ARRA 2009 says it will expand electronic medical records, it allocates billions to “beef up” the security imposed by HIPAA. This of course reduces the free exchange of medical data, which increases errors and prevents learning.

Effect on the economy
At present, the Government is trying to stimulate our stagnant economy. What will ObamaCare do to the economy? While it makes easy political fodder to attack the extremely wealthy, when you super-tax them bad things happen. Ask Great Britain: they tried it. The super-wealthy either find ways to protect their money by making it non-taxable or they became…less wealthy. Either way, they will neither spend nor invest, just hoard and protect. In the midst of a severe recession, ObamaCare will remove a major driver of economic growth.

For hospitals, the cuts in MediCare and MediCaid will be devastating. Right now, hospitals are losing money on these patients. They have to make it up by ‘over’-charging privately insured patients, called revenue shifting. What are they going to do after further cuts? Answer: shift revenue even more or go out of business. Can you think of a third option? I cannot.

The penalty aspect of ObamaCare is supposed to raise $200 billion. [Where do they get these numbers – from the twilight zone?] Employers who now do not offer health insurance benefits cannot because of the cost. Penalizing them will just take more money out of their pockets and simply drive them out of business. Then their employees will have neither insurance nor a job.

Individuals who choose not to buy health insurance do so because they too cannot afford it. Does the government really think that imposing a financial penalty – increasing the out-of-pocket cost for the non-wealthy individual –will suddenly make that person go out and buy what he could not afford in the first place?

Just because a jerk says it doesn’t make it false.
Years ago, I learned an important lesson. Just because a jerk, someone I disliked, said something did not make it untrue. We need to evaluate the message more than the messenger. The Republicans are currently the ‘bad guys.’ They may oppose the President’s Plan largely on partisan grounds. Nonetheless, when they say this Plan will not work, that statement (regardless whose mouth it comes out of) is true. Whether it is CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf or Rush Limbaugh saying that ObamaCare will fail, both are right.

ObamaCare:
•    Will not increase access to care.
•    Will not halt or even slow the rise of national healthcare expenditures.
•    Will increase errors but not quality.
•    Will increase the acute shortages of healthcare personnel.
•    Will increase our already unsupportable national deficit.

ObamaCare will not reinject care into healthcare. It will backfire and as a bonus, ObamaCare will extend the current recession.

System MD

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post Post to Yahoo Buzz Buzz This Post Post to Delicious Delicious Post to Digg Digg This Post Post to Facebook Facebook Post to StumbleUpon Stumble This Post

  • No related posts

3 comments ↓

#1 ObamaCare – another fix-that-backfires — Medical Malprocess on 10.28.09 at 11:30 am

[...] Cost According to the GAO and other reliable sources, ObamaCare will add $1 trillion to the deficit. Worse, taxes (penalties) will be imposed on businesses that [...]

#2 My Homepage on 03.14.12 at 4:43 pm

… [Trackback]…

[...] There you will find 28196 more Infos: thesystemmd.com/?p=387 [...]…

#3 Princes on 10.24.12 at 4:19 am

Every state will be slightly dffnereit, but I’ll give you the proverbial swine slap across the face about why Medicare is generally the worst thing invented by modern liberalism in this nation, in only ONE word: Access.In my state, there are 1,127 primary care Medical Doctors, and 130 Osteopaths in family practice. That’s 1,257 doctors that handle routine care (non-emergency care, not otherwise in a named specialty).Of that 1,257, less than 11% accept Medicare assignment. CMS provides these figures, so my point is irrefutable. As others have noted, Medicare pays a fraction of an already deep discounted rate that is substantially below what providers call usual and customary (a fancy phrase for retail prices ).When a doctor refuses to sign up for Medicare assignment, they still get paid for treating Medicare patients, but they get EVEN LESS than the already bottom dollar (read: guaranteed loss) reimbursements of the doctors that willingly accept Medicare assignment. This is not my opinion. This is verifiable, irrefutable fact, and the source is CMS. Nobody knows better how bad Medicare is than Medicare itself.Of the several hundred doctors I advise in my practice, more than 95% go out of their way to refuse Medicare patients. Some go as far as sending out birthday letters prior to age 65 politely asking the patient to find another doctor (if you schedule an appointment after age 65, they aren’t always so polite some instruct their staff to refer Medicare patients to CMS for the very short list of doctors willing to work for the absolute lowest wage a doctor can possibly earn).What this means to you is this: More than 89% of primary care doctors do NOT want Medicare patients, because they are guaranteed to lose money on those patients.What this also means to you is this: Private insurance subsidizes Medicare in an off the books fashion, via cost-shifting. Take away private insurance, and not only would Medicare go broke virtually overnight, providers would vanish faster than a modern liberal can fail at math (and they fail 100% of the time faster than any other group).Doctors aren’t going to work for free. Neither will nurses, and other support staff (and you can’t force them outside of a chattel slavery system of forced labor). They will all seek other ways to earn a living. This will lower access even further from the abysmal point it is now, and lower access ALWAYS equals higher costs, lower quality, and more early deaths among those modern liberals who failed at math so fast.Other points of interest: Largest and fastest growing form of crime in the USA is identity theft. Among that large group of crimes, the single fastest growing aspect is medical Identity theft. A Medicare card has a street value of $500 to $700 ten times that of a stolen credit or debit card.The second most profitable crime in America today? Medicare fraud. The source for that is the same government that built the failed collectivist system. The smart criminals are leaving the drug trade and turning to Medicare fraud. The numbers are staggering. A mid-level drug trafficker might make $300,000 a year, taking extraordinary risks. The same crook can make $30,000,000 stealing from Medicare, and never get shot at.Talent and capital go where it is rewarded, and stay where it is well treated. This axiom applies to the talent that goes into medicine, and it also applies to talent when it comes to criminals seeking to profit from the system that has ZERO financial incentive to fight fraud (ONLY a for-profit enterprise will root out the thieves, and find ways to detect them before they cause real damage the government just asks for more funding to replace what was stolen).

Leave a Comment